Welding high carbon steel to mild steel is a challenge, but it’s not impossible. I’ve worked on this type of weld many times, and I can tell you that getting it right requires understanding the differences between these two metals. High carbon steel is strong and hard, while mild steel is softer and more ductile. The issue is that high carbon steel tends to crack when welded due to its brittleness, especially when exposed to high heat.
Image by nsarc
If you’ve ever tried to weld these two together without the right approach, you’ve probably seen cracking, weak welds, or distortion. The key to success is choosing the right welding method, filler material, and pre- and post-weld treatments. Let’s go through everything you need to know so you can weld high carbon steel to mild steel with confidence.
Differences Between High Carbon Steel and Mild Steel
Before starting the welding process, it’s important to know how these two metals behave.
| Property | High Carbon Steel | Mild Steel |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon Content | 0.6% to 1.5% | 0.05% to 0.25% |
| Hardness | Hard and brittle | Soft and ductile |
| Weldability | Difficult due to high hardness | Easy to weld |
| Strength | Very strong but prone to cracking | Less strong but flexible |
| Heat Treatment Response | Can be hardened with heat | Does not respond to hardening like high carbon steel |
The biggest problem when welding these metals is the carbon content in high carbon steel. The higher the carbon content, the greater the risk of cracking. Mild steel, on the other hand, is much more forgiving and easy to weld.
Choosing the Right Welding Method
The welding method you choose makes a big difference in the final result. Some methods work better than others, especially when dealing with different carbon levels.
Stick Welding (SMAW)
Stick welding is a great choice because it works well with both mild steel and high carbon steel. The key is using the right electrode. A low-hydrogen rod like 7018 is the best option because it reduces the risk of cracking.
MIG Welding (GMAW)
MIG welding can be used, but it requires a special filler wire. ER70S-6 is a common choice for welding mild steel, but for high carbon steel, a filler with nickel or higher strength is better. Using a preheat before welding is necessary to reduce stress and avoid cracking.
TIG Welding (GTAW)
TIG welding offers precise control, making it a good choice for welding high carbon steel to mild steel. The challenge is that TIG welding requires more skill, and the right filler metal is crucial. ER70S-2 or a nickel-based filler can help manage the hardness difference.
Flux-Cored Arc Welding (FCAW)
This method is similar to MIG but uses flux-cored wire. It’s a good option for outdoor welding because it doesn’t require shielding gas. However, it produces more spatter and requires careful selection of the right filler wire.
Selecting the Right Filler Metal
Choosing the correct filler material is one of the most important steps. Since high carbon steel is prone to cracking, the filler metal should have properties that help balance the differences between these two metals.
| Filler Metal | Best For | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| E7018 (Stick Welding) | General welding, reduces cracking | Strong, low-hydrogen | Requires proper storage to prevent moisture |
| ER70S-2 (TIG Welding) | Good for dissimilar metals | Provides a smooth weld | Requires precise heat control |
| ER80S-D2 (MIG/TIG) | High-strength applications | Good for high carbon steel | Requires preheat and post-weld treatment |
| Nickel-Based Fillers | Best for extreme hardness differences | Reduces stress, prevents cracking | Expensive |
If the goal is strength with minimal cracking, E7018 for stick welding or ER70S-2 for TIG welding is usually the safest choice. If the high carbon steel part is hardened, a nickel-based filler will reduce brittleness.
Preheating to Prevent Cracking
One of the most critical steps when welding high carbon steel is preheating. Because high carbon steel cools quickly, it tends to form cracks. Preheating slows down this cooling process, reducing stress in the weld area.
Recommended Preheat Temperatures
- Mild Steel: No preheat needed.
- High Carbon Steel (0.6% – 1.0% Carbon): 300°F – 500°F.
- High Carbon Steel (Above 1.0% Carbon): 500°F – 800°F.
You can use a propane torch or induction heater to preheat the material. The goal is to heat both pieces evenly before starting the weld.
Controlling Heat Input During Welding
High carbon steel is sensitive to heat, so you need to control your welding technique. Too much heat can cause excessive hardness and brittleness, leading to cracks.
Here’s how to control heat input:
- Use short weld passes instead of long continuous welds.
- Reduce amperage if the weld is overheating.
- Keep the arc length short to avoid excess heat buildup.
- Allow the weld area to cool slowly after each pass.
Post-Weld Heat Treatment
After welding, high carbon steel needs to cool down slowly to avoid hardening and cracking. This is called post-weld heat treatment (PWHT), and it helps relieve internal stresses in the weld.
How to Apply Post-Weld Heat Treatment
- Heat the welded area to 500°F – 800°F (depending on the carbon content).
- Hold the temperature for 30-60 minutes to allow stress relief.
- Let the metal cool down slowly by covering it with insulation blankets or placing it in warm sand.
Avoiding Common Mistakes
- Skipping preheat – This is the #1 reason why high carbon steel welds crack. Always preheat!
- Using the wrong filler metal – A standard mild steel filler won’t work well with high carbon steel. Use low-hydrogen or nickel-based fillers.
- Welding too fast – Rushing through the weld increases heat stress and causes cracking. Take your time.
- Allowing rapid cooling – If you let the weld cool too quickly, it becomes brittle. Always use a slow cooling process.
Conclusion
Welding high carbon steel to mild steel is not as simple as welding two similar metals, but with the right approach, you can achieve a strong, reliable weld. The key is proper preparation, correct filler metal selection, and careful heat control.
Stick welding with an E7018 rod or TIG welding with ER70S-2 is often the best choice. Preheating before welding and using a slow cooling process afterward will prevent cracking and ensure a durable weld.
If you take these steps seriously, you’ll have a solid, long-lasting weld that won’t break under stress. Welding is all about patience and technique—master these, and you’ll have no trouble joining high carbon steel to mild steel successfully.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you weld high carbon steel without preheating?
It’s not recommended. Without preheating, the weld will cool too fast and crack.
What is the best welding method for high carbon steel to mild steel?
Stick welding with E7018 rods or TIG welding with ER70S-2 filler works best.
Why does high carbon steel crack after welding?
It becomes brittle due to rapid cooling and high internal stress. Preheating and post-weld heat treatment can prevent this.
Can you MIG weld high carbon steel to mild steel?
Yes, but you need a filler wire that handles the hardness difference, such as ER80S-D2 or a nickel-based wire.
What happens if you use a mild steel rod on high carbon steel?
The weld will likely crack because the mild steel rod won’t handle the hardness difference. Always use a low-hydrogen or high-strength filler.
